Selected Posts - /r/UnearthedArcana

April 11, 2022

This article contains the raw data collected during my small research on how people modify the rules of D&D 5e in the Reddit community /r/UnearthedArcana.

Every selected post is presented with key data points and screenshots. In addition, the web page of every post was archived. You can download these archived pages to look at the comments under the posts yourself.

Post 1

« Homebrew mechanic to make Intelligence stats interesting. »

Post name: « Homebrew mechanic to make Intelligence stats interesting. » ;

Link : https://www.reddit.com/r/UnearthedArcana/comments/qxc1xs/homebrew_mechanic_to_
make_intelligence_stats/
;

Score : 1 545 points (92 % upvoted) ;

Comments : 161 ;

Number of rewards : 4 ;

Post type : new game mechanic ;

Classification : popular post.
Download this post's archive.

Post 2

« Oath of the Working Class Paladin: Protect the workers, incite the revolution. »

Post name: « Oath of the Working Class Paladin: Protect the workers, incite the revolution. » ;

Link : https://www.reddit.com/gallery/r1e9vz ;

Score : 1 216 points (91 % upvoted) ;

Comments : 119 ;

Number of rewards : 9 ;

Post type : class option ;

Classification : popular post.
Download this post's archive.

Post 3

« Prestige Classes | A take on prestige classes within 5e DnD, with 10 different prestige class options to choose from »

Post name: « Prestige Classes | A take on prestige classes within 5e DnD, with 10 different prestige class options to choose from » ;

Link : https://www.reddit.com/r/UnearthedArcana/comments/r0awec/prestige_classes_a_take_
on_prestige_classes/
;

Score : 983 points  (98 % upvoted) ;

Comments : 100 ;

Number of rewards : 4 ;

Post type : class option ;

Classification : popular post ;
Download this post's archive.

Post 4

« Rogue Optional Feature: Debilitate - Spend your Sneak Attack dice to inflict debuffs on your foes! »

Post Name: « Rogue Optional Feature: Debilitate - Spend your Sneak Attack dice to inflict debuffs on your foes! »

Link : https://www.reddit.com/gallery/qq1cv8 ;

Score : 1 583 points (98 % upvoted) ;

Comments : 104 ;

Number of rewards : 16 ;

Post type : class option ;

Classification : popular post.
Download this post's archive.

Post 5

« Some potions to help your party »

Post name: « Some potions to help your party »

Link : https://www.reddit.com/gallery/qpctgj

Score : 2 259 points (98 % upvoted) ;

Comments : 113 ;

Number of rewards : 9 ;

Post type : magical item ;

Classification : popular post.
Download this post's archive.

Post 6

« heavyarms | True Strike | maybe we can make it less terrible? »

Post name: « heavyarms | True Strike | maybe we can make it less terrible? »

Link : https://www.reddit.com/r/Unearthed Arcana/comments/qznxdi/heavyarms_ true_strike_maybe_we_can_make_it_less/ ;

Score : 841 points (85 % upvoted) ;

Comments : 183 ;

Number of rewards : 0 ;

Post type : révision de sort ;

Classification : controversial post.
Download this post's archive.

Post 7

« Sword of 10,000 Cuts — A real samurai's sword »

Post name: « Sword of 10,000 Cuts — A real samurai's sword »

Link : https://www.reddit.com/r/Unearthed Arcana/comments/qrliyc/sword_of_10000 _cuts_a_real_samurais_sword/ ;

Score : 1 360 points (80 % upvoted) ;

Comments : 165 ;

Number of posts : 3 ;

Post types : magical items ;

Classification : controversial posts.
Download this post's archive.

Post 8

« The Martial Artist - a Fighter Archetype »

Post name: « The Martial Artist - a Fighter Archetype »

Link : https://www.reddit.com/r/Unearthed Arcana/comments/qrliyc/sword_of_10000 _cuts_a_real_samurais_sword/ ;

Score : 13 points (69 % upvoted) ;

Comments : 12 ;

Number of rewards : 0 ;

Post type : option de classe ;

Classification : controversial posts.
Download this post's archive.

Post 9

« Way of the Primordial Elements - Subclass (OC ART) »

Post name: « Way of the Primordial Elements - Subclass (OC ART) »

Link : https://www.reddit.com/r/UnearthedArcana/comments/qt7g56/way_of_the_primordial_
elements_subclass_oc_art/
;

Score : 12 points (68 % upvote) ;

Comments : 16 ;

Number of rewards : 0 ;

Post type : class option ;

Classification : controversial post.
Download this post's archive.

Post 10

« Witch Lance - Gods Damn It, I Revised Witch Bolt. Are You Happy Now? »

Post name: « Witch Lance - Gods Damn It, I Revised Witch Bolt. Are You Happy Now? »

Link : https://www.reddit.com/r/UnearthedArcana/comments/qv3ktp/witch_lance_gods_damn
_it_i_revised_witch_bolt_are/
;

Score : 91 points (85 % upvoted) ;

Comments : 32 ;

Number of rewards : 0 ;

Post type : spell revision ;

Classification : controversial post.
Download this post's archive.

Read other articles

April 11, 2022
Selected Posts - /r/UnearthedArcana
April 11, 2022
Breaking the rules correctly: changing the rules of D&D 5e on /r/UnearthedArcana

For my Master’s Thesis, I study why tabletop role-playing game players change the rules of that type of game. During my Video Games and Society course at UQÀM, I decided to work on a small-scale qualitative study related to my subject by studying the rule modification practices of a small online community. This article is […]

May 24, 2021
Canonizing my player’s backstories: The Vampires of Varmand campaign

This is an after-action report about my backstory canonization method, in my "Vampire of Varmand" campaign.

May 24, 2021
Making backstories canon: creating stories with your players

The "method" I developed to create more involved backstories with my players in Dungeons and Dragons.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram